Crotty & Son Law Firm

Home Attorney Cases Client Testimonials

Kelly O’Kell v. Deb Haaland- US Department of Interior

This is a case brought under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA). Kelly O’Kell worked for the U.S. Department of the Interior at the Agency’s Ephrata, Washington office as a Realty Specialist. She applied for a GS-12 Project Manager position. At the time of her application she was 56 years old. Ms. O’Kell did not get the job. A member of the hiring panel told Ms. O’Kell that the Agency decided to hire a someone who was “young and perky and going to bring new energy to the office.”

Ms. O’Kell immediately complained to Agency management about the discrimination. Management then embarked on a retaliatory course of conduct that ultimately led to Ms. O’Kell’s firing. A copy of Ms. O’Kell’s complaint is available here.

After filing suit Ms. O’Kell retained an expert witness who has written an opinion that the Agency’s treatment of Ms. O’Kell deviated from well established Human Resources (HR) norms. The Agency tried to exclude Ms. O’Kell’s expert from offering her opinion. The Court denied the Agency’s attempt to exclude Ms. O’Kell’s expert.

The Agency recently asked the Court to dismiss Ms. O’Kell’s entire lawsuit. Ms. O’Kell’s response to the Agency’s request and statement of facts in support of that response are available here and here.

On April 8, 2020, the court denied the Agency’s motion for summary judgment.

On April 12, 2022, following a two-week trial, the Court found that the Agency discriminated and retaliated against Ms. O’Kell and awarded her $1,683,351 plus injunctive relief. A copy of the Court’s Order is below:


A copy of Ms. O’Kell’s petition for attorneys’ fees, costs, and litigation expenses is available below:

On July 8, 2022, the Court granted the majority of Plaintiff’s motion for attorneys’ fees and costs. A copy of the Court order is below.

Back to Cases


Suzanne Hawk v. Dog Sciences d/b/a Unleashed Academy & Mary Davies

An employer cannot misclassify employees as "independent contractors" in order to avoid having to pa...

Read more

Boyd v. Acro Inc. et. al.

Chico's Pizza, which does business as Acro Inc., hired Ms. Boyd in 2016. As time wore on its manager...

Read more

Hamilton v. Newport Hospital & Health Services

Newport Hospital & Health Services hired Laura Hamilton to serve as its Chief Human Resources Of...

Read more

Maria McSwain v. World Fuel Services

Maria McSwain worked at World Fuel Services as a Senior Human Resources Ge...

Read more

Valentine Fertitta v. Federal Bureau of Investigation

Valentine Fertitta is an FBI agent and an officer in the US Marine Corps R...

Read more

Kristi Horn v. U.S. Department of Agriculture

The USDA employed Ms. Horn for over 12 years. Up until early-2020, Ms. Hor...

Read more

Eric Schwartz v. Rampart Aviation, et. al.

Rampart Aviation, LLC is a federal government contractor. Rampart employed ...

Read more

Justin Carlile v. Waste Connections

Waste Connections employed Justin Carlile beginning in May 2019. It promoted Mr. Carlile in Februa...

Read more

Edward Cancilla v. Sandia National Laboratories

Mr. Cancilla began working for Sandia in 2010. In 2013 the U.S. Navy Reserves called Mr. Cancilla to...

Read more

Charles Graham v. HNI Hospitalists of Idaho

Dr. Charles Graham worked for HNI as a Physician and Medical Director beginning in early-2020. In mi...

Read more